Make your own free website on Tripod.com

Pendapat Pelawat Tidak Mewakili Pendirian Jawatankuasa Suqiu

 

Pendapat Pelawat

 

Nama 

MUN

Alamat Elektronik 

SMUN_OCTYAHOO.COM

Pendapat 

SAYA BERPENDAPAT SUPAYA KERAAJAAN HARUS BERLAKU ADIL DAN MEMBERI KEMUDAHAN PINJAMAN UNTUK KAUM BUKAN BUMIPUTRA BERNIAGA .

 

Nama 

MUN

Alamat Elektronik 

SMUN_OCT@YAHOO.COM

Pendapat 

SAYA BERPENDAPAT BAHAWA SUQIU HARUS MERAYU KEPADA KERAJAAN AGAR MERENDAHKAN CUKAI UNTUK MERINGANKAN BEBAN RAKYAT YANG BERPENDAPATAN RENDAH   
DAN MEMAJUKAN NEGERI NEGERI DI MALAYSIA SEPERTI PERAK , PAHANG ......... DAN TIDAK MENUMPUKAN PERHATIAN DI KUALA LUMPUR SAHAJA.

Nama 

Anonymous

Alamat Elektronik 

unspecified

Pendapat 

In the new-Internet and information technology era, our beloved country must progress and modernise the idea of democracy and human rights.   
If one race is denied the rights because of some precedence of priority allocated to another "elite" son-of-the-land, then it would be an issue of disgrace in a free world that is becoming more and more boundaryless.   
Sure, I as a non-bumi Malaysian enjoy all full rights such as voting, (partial) free-speech, education, etc., but implicitly, I am also short-changed in the supposed rights that I should enjoy like any other citizens.   
Implicitly, there is absolutely no equality. No equal opportunities (in education, etc.). Many very bright students are forced to study overseas and later serve as professionals abroad when they score as well (or better) as the bumiputras in local pre-u when they are denied a place in the stream in local uni, a large proportion which has been "reserved" for the bumis.   
Why not play fair and make entry to the uni based on achievements rather than race? The same goes for the business arena, when taxpayers' money (I'm sure the Chinese pay a heck a lot of tax!) are used as subsidies for bumiputra startups?   
In short our government needs to have a fresher perspective of racial democracy, or else the people will begin to dawn upon themselves and wake up one day to start to dislike the current state of unfairness.

Nama 

non-racist

Alamat Elektronik 

Pendapat 

for any multi-racial country, peace and understanding among different races should be encouraged and it should start at the very top. however, i malaysia, you find the top starting all these nonsense of racial discrimination itself.   
  
i still remember a situation where such action by the government is clearly racial in nature. the one very special gift from the bn government to the people of cheras on the national day of 1990 - the commencement of the cheras toll.   
  
i remember that all vehicles were to pass the toll, even for those staying in bandar tun razak. they will have to go up to the taman cheras roundabout and turn back to head towards their destination. this would mean payment of two tolls @ rm1 each. however, for the purposes of "exempting" these people from paying such "heavy penalties", a special by-pass road (which did not exist prior to the toll collection) was built at the 4th mile roundabout. this is a very clear example of "providing special concession to one race" while discriminating others.   
  
to aggravate matters, they closed an existing private road through the christian cemetary. i believe that road is a private road and what right has the government or the toll-collection company to close that road, just to make sure their business flourished. the incident of the tractor driver who attempted to cut off a dirt road joining upper cheras and lower cheras through taman midah showed a further high-handed action of those in power to force the people of cheras to pay for their plans. we are in a democratic country and we should not be forced by those in power to do things against our will. in the first place these people forgot who put them up there and where their salaries come from - does every single citizen want to pay someone to give them headaches?   
  
it was also one of my observations then that the collection of the rm1 toll served no purpose at all. every vehicle practically lined up to pay the rm1 and find themselves in another jam after paying. this is what i call "jam to pay and pay to jam". i really did not understand the purpose of paying the rm1 then. did the bn government think that by paying the rm1, the traffic condition in cheras will improve? if so, i suggest that the bn government take a further study of the traffic patterns in the city of kl or even nationwide, to find out which areas in the city or country are jammed and start collecting exhorbitant tolls to ease the traffic.   
  
based on a simple calculation, i have worked out what it cost then to travel on jalan cheras alone over a period of one year. assuming that i travelled only one trip a day, it would cost me a total of rm2X30X12=rm720. on the other hand, i believe what i pay as road tax on my car was then a mere rm202 only - which entitles me to travel on all "government road" in malaysia. how come i have to pay more than three time the price just to travel on jalan cheras? the explanation provided by the pm then was "we collect this toll from the people of cheras to overcome traffic problems in other parts of the city of kl" it is a laughing stock - why only the people of cheras have to pay for the development of the kl traffic system? why penalize the people of cheras alone? is it because of the distribution of population in terms of race? or on what basis was he making the statement? after all, i believe the government has never upgraded the road in cheras for the past 4 decades when the area was then full of rubber estates. today, you find that the rubber estates have all become housing estates, and the same old road exists. for some small upgrading, the government wants to collect toll. i fail to understand where the money collected as "conversion fees" for converting the lands in cheras from agriculture to building have gone. weren't these fees meant to be used for upgrading infrastructure in cheras to cope with developments? isn't the road (the main road that connects the whole of cheras to the city) part of the infrastructure that deserves attention? just where did all these money go to? developers paid for these and the money came from purchasers of properties in cheras who had hoped to stay in cheras peacefully after paying such price. but instead they find themselves paying even more (and it looks like there will not be any end - the present toll is supposed to end in 2003 after twelve years, but it looks like it is a common thing with the bn government "there is no end once the ball starts rolling" - especially in terms of toll collection)   
  
from all these, we can conclude one thing, the bn government is practising racial discrimination itself while pointing its fingers at others, accusing them of the practice. if at all the government is out to promote racial harmony, it should first rid itself of such "dirty image" and show the people that it is itself a "clean" body promoting racial harmony.

Nama 

An Overseas Malaysian

Alamat Elektronik 

@land of the red maple

Pendapat 


Datuk Seri Dr Mahathir Mohamad has insulted and shamed the entire Chinese community in multiracial and multicultural Malaysia by his venomous utterance on National Day.   
  
He, wittingly or deliberately, accused the SUQIU Committee for being the defunct communists of the l950s and the Islamic rebels of 2000 just because the latter circulated the fair and reasonable 17-point election appeal to all political parties prior to the l999 national election, and ironically had the "endorsement" of the cabinet as well.   
  
Why then did Dr. Mahatir went back on the cabinet's acceptance in "principle" of this SUQIU document of national importance?   
  
The answer is quite obvious. He needs a scapegoat to pounce on in order, hopefully, to galvanize the fragmented Malay community on his side. He also wanted to frighten the SUQIU committee into retracting its appeals.   
  
But his gamble failed because the divided Malay community, most of them, didn't buy his way of hitting below the belt, otherwise there would have been an ugly racial riot or two, just as on May 13, l969.   
  
He thought that he could cowed the Chinese community into silence so that it would not say anything that he didn't like to hear or read.   
  
Well, the Chinese community has been taken in as suckers and gullibly supported the Barisan Nasional in the last election. Did it learn a painful lesson? I hope it has.   
  
Ironically, Dr. Mahatir invited the Premier of Communist China, Zhu Rongji to visit Malaysia prior to the last year's national election.   
  
Also, when Dr. Mahatir was in New York recently to address the United Nations, he embraced of all guests, the uncomprising communist leader of Cuba, Dr Fidel Castro.   
  
These two incidents showed without a shadow of doubt the vanities of Dr. Mahatir.   
  
In other words, Dr. Mahatir seems to say: " You don't do as what I do, but do as what I tell you to do, or else..."   
  
Similarly, what is good for the goose isn't good for the gender and all that jazz...   
  
Perhaps labelling SIQIU as the l950s communists by Dr. Mahatir was intended to evoke the wrath of the Malay community against both SIQIU and the Chinese community in Malaysia. [Dangers of communism!].   
  
Finally, let me say that unless the united Chinese community stand up courageously, righteously and fairly for their native rights which it should deserve as representing the true citizens of the Malaysian soil, conversely, by remaining passive, docile, and submissive will eventually be regulated to the status of being second class citizens. Then the Chinese community has only itself to blame.   
  
Let there be a fair, prosperous and just Malaysia for all its inhabitants, regardless of race, creed and religion.   
  
Goodbye to you all from the Land of the Red Maple [Canada].

Nama 

Roney koh Ming Hong

Alamat Elektronik 

suqiu@malaysia.net

Pendapat 

I think all the 17 demands are reasonable! We have waited for over 42 years since the Independence of Malaya Federation.   
  
We should uphold our right as the citizen to demand for equal beyond races, because Malaysia is a multi racial country, we(non-bumiputras) are not second class race, we are equal as other races(the bumiputras), and was the hope of our nation too!!   
  
Hoping that this demands would influence the Malaysian Chinese society in the East Malaysia. MCA it is the right time for you to perform your duty as representative to majority chinese in this country. Help suqiu, help us ethnic chinese, to avoid any discrimination from others (who are inpower to do so). Stop criticise suqiu of being too extreme!! Ask yourself (MCA) have you really perform your duty as representative to your race, as the majority put their trust and hope on you (MCA)during the election? Please do understand what we gone through these few decades, we are being discrimated!!   
  
MCA please don't be another NATO (No Action Talk Only) after Indonesia Gov.(regarding May 1998 Racial tensions).   
We do not want to become any like our fellow ethnic chinese in Indonesia.   
"Prevention is better than solving crisis"!!   
  
Dato Seri Dr. Mahathir, please do understand that our demands was not too extreme! We are not raising up crisis to against the people's choice government! But so far the democracy in our country are lacking behind!! Especially regarding the human right and discrimination are very clear for decades!!   
  
I knew that it is hard for you Dr.M, your race are the majority and they want to kept their special right for lasting. But if a nation wanted to be a well developed one, we should first settle our inner problems!   
  
"No discrimination please!!"   
  
Dr.M, refering to your statement in The Star dated Sept.24,2000,You've said that "Govt. believes in intergrating, not assimilating, various races for peace", but I would like to ask (my point of view), how we want to be   
intergrated if we can't be assimilated?   
  
The 17 demands, are reasonable Dr. M, we are not communist! We are not Al-Maunnah! Suqiu are neither political party nor Religious party! Suqiu are committe representing chinese community!! Labelise Suqiu as communist and Al-Maunnah are unacceptable, these matter upset chinese community!! However, lets by gones be by gones, lets us focus on the demands first!! Research and discuss the demands over and over until both sides are able to work it out! We are the rightful citizen, we have our right to speak out! We don't want to continuosly discriminated! When we asked for demands, we are titled to terrorists and criminals/outlaws!!   
  
Please Stop This!   
No more NATO(No Action Talk Only)   
  
Email me, give me, give us answers that we all longing for!! Once again, I stress The 17 Demands are reasonable!

Nama 

Roney koh Ming Hong

Alamat Elektronik 

roneykoh@tm.net.my

Pendapat 

I think all the 17 demands are reasonable! We have waited for over 42 years since the Independence of Malaya Federation.   
We should uphold our right as the citizen to demand for equal beyond races, because Malaysia is a multi racial country, we(non-bumiputras) are not second class race, we are equal as other races(the bumiputras), and was the hope of our nation!!

Nama 

Top_Gun

Alamat Elektronik 

Out there

Pendapat 

I'm a overseas Chinese.   
I was born in Malaysia   
I support the 17-point appeal of Suqui which should be a guiding light for all Malaysian. It is riduculous to suggest that these points would evoke the anger of other races in Malaysia or question the special rights of the Malays. Anyway it would be vain for Suqui had it done so because whether it likes it or not, the issue of Malay special rights is already enshrine in the country's constitution. My question is that the Malays have already enjoyed these special priveledges for 43 years since independence, don't tell me that they have not achieved the 30 % economic status in the country. If so, than all Malaysians must ask why is it so and why are the mass of Malays still just as poor and still form the bottom of the economic heap. If there are no changes to implement this so-called special rights policies in a proper way, the majority of the Malays will continue to maintain the status quo at the expenses of other races. I think the worse off of all the three main races are the Indians which should deserve to have some special help from the Barisan Nasional Government. I can still that the economic pie in the country is not properly shared by all the races. Why? Some things are wrong and these ought to be righted immediately.   
Finally, it is unfair, prejudical and insulting to accuse SUQIU as communists of the l950s or Islamic/cultic fanatics.   
Dr Mahatir Mohamad is not only unfair and a big mouth, he is in a way fanning the flames of racism. Coming on, Mahathir, give the Chinese a break. At least you owe them for your Barisan success in the last election. The whole world of the overseas Chinese are watching your situation in Malaysia, Suqiu. All the best to all of you. Take good care and be careful next time. Don't be taken in so lightly.

Nama 

MALAYSIAN INDIAN

Alamat Elektronik 

NOT WORTH IT

Pendapat 

I ONLY WISH THE INDIAN COMMUNITY HAS ALL THE GUTS THAT THE CHINESE HAVE. WE ARE BEING TREATED LIKE 2nd CLASS CITIZENS!!!. CARRY ON YOU ARE DOING A GOOD JOB.

Nama 

wecitizen

Alamat Elektronik 

wecitizen@hotmail.com

Pendapat 

SUQIU DILEMMA   
So Mahathir had told Suqiu: "No More communal demand!!"   
Suqiu, next time plssssssssssssssssssss:   
1. Invite other NGOs such as SAM,ABIM & etc which represent   
other community & sector in drafting the appeal.   
2. Come out with "Malaysian 17 Appeal" not "Chinese 17   
appeal" (Although the current appeal is a Universal &   
cross community). So nobody can't said the appeal is only   
for chinese interest.   
3. Plan your step wisely, learn from current mistake.   
  
You must do it now!!! Don't wait until the next General Election.

Nama 

H.K.Lim

Alamat Elektronik 

kaisim2000@hotmail.com

Pendapat 

The Editor, We know that what the committee do is good for   the country but only blown out of propertion by an irrational group out   to gain political support. Some of these people are wolves in sheep clothings.   
Be careful. Anyway, SUQIU you have done well and deserve   the people`s support.KEEP ON MOVING. HK.

Nama 

nataraja

Alamat Elektronik 

nataraja@ms43.url.com.tw

Pendapat 

Dear Suqiu,   
  
Vanakkam.   
  
I still find difficult to support your 17 points of Appeal because it has something wrong in itself. I would try to write a commentary essay about this and published at Malaysian mass media as possible.   
  
warm sincerely   
nataraja

Nama 

phoon

Alamat Elektronik 

phoonx_23@hotmail.com

Pendapat 

i aggree with the revolution. but i feel seek with my races. why should our races strive for this activities? why don't all of us especially malaysian give the moral support for this suqiu. ask all the penan, kadazan, kadayan and whatsoever including malay races to join this suqiu. I don't think without their support it willbe obviously that this suqiu will seems like "pentingkan kaum sahaja" so thats all folks! hope we can strive together and uphold the right! don't just blaming with each other.

Nama 

Hafeez

Alamat Elektronik 

Pendapat 

So-called Bumiputra rights and privileges have been somewhat the bane to certain progress. Especially where higher education is concerned. The quota of non-bumi/bumi is, I believe, an appalling apllication whereby some gets in despite not having the merit. While I certainly agree with some of the content, I have a feeling that an outright applying of the 17 points are at best impractical and would lead to further imbalance. This is not to anyone's advantage.   
Case in point is in higher education quota. Imagine if this is not done, the number of actaul Bumi students who could actually go in based on their grades gained in STPM would be remarkedly reduce. And furthermore it is a known fact that Bumis lag when it comes to sending their children to private colleges, from lack of responsibility to outright lack of planning. But it has got to GRADUALLY go. This I truly believe to be needed as to not jolt the imbalances to our utter dissappointment. Both proponents as well as opponents of the 17 points.   
Any change cannot be one that is done immediately. In other words there has to be consensus. Despite the show of hands from "liberalised" Bumi, the majority do not comprehend such high and lofty ideals. What matters more is when their children do not receive a single offer from any of the local universities nor the loans from government agencies.   
These lofty ideals may sound good, but, as pointed out by some readers, it is only words, and most certainly following Western ideals. Is this something which we truly wish to embrace? Why?   
  
PM likening Suqui to the communist, I beleive, stem from the insistence in seeing the 17 points implementation, without hving due regards to the possible negative overall impact on race relations. Do not look only at the middle and far more liberalised Bumi and Non Bumi communities. They are all already reaping the harvest from the consensual sacrifiecs made by all our forefathers, nothwithstanding race and religion. Let's not forget this.   
  
Was there at all any consultation done with Bumi-based association when the 17 point was drafted?   
Hard to beleive if there was any.

Nama 

champion of justice

Alamat Elektronik 

nil

Pendapat 

i am of the opinion that pampering any one group of citizens will only lead to this group of people relying on the government for their daily bread. they will not learn to stand up on their own feet for everything is well prepared for them - they get these without any effort. not forgetting that they have been pampered for the last 43 years (or at least 29 since the imposition of the new economic policy). which ever is the case, it is time for them to grow up and stand on their own feet. it is simply disgraceful for these people to continue their existence solely relying on "charity" from the government (whose money comes from all citizens of the nation). what's more the government is calling for "closed door policies" during the currency crisis. how can we close our doors when we cannot even be self-sufficient? to be self-sufficient, each and every citizen must contribute to the effort and if any one group of citizens are "exempted" from that, it would be very unfair to the other groups when success is achieved and this "exclusive" group just comes in to share the fruits. so, be self sufficient, stand up fellow malaysians!!

Nama 

y-t-chiamղ

Alamat Elektronik 

chiam174@tm.net.my

Pendapat 

it seems lacking the analysis of the old mahathir's speech   
so far.I hope someone will post the interpretation of the strange speech by Mahathir with more politically and academic analysis.   
i'll contribute one or two of my own article in chinese very soon.   
By the way, thanks Suqiu and aslo Mahathir as well,they both giving a good chance for us to review the one of the reality Malaysia issues.whereas there's a controversial,there's a consensus.   
  
y-t-chiam

Nama 

A Chinese Student

Alamat Elektronik 

nil

Pendapat 

I believe everything in the 17 points are what TRUE Malaysians have always wanted. And I'm absolutely confident that anyone who wants to see a better Malaysia will support you, Suqiu. Those who don't can say whatever they want but in the end, the TRUTH will survive.

Nama 

Malaysian Malaysian

Alamat Elektronik 

chiayk2000@hotmail.com

Pendapat 

I find recent comments and statements by our PM very disheartening and sad, especially his Merdeka Message.
I had hung our Malaysian Flag on my car, but has decided to take it out after hearing our PM's message.   
I have one question for everyone to ponder.   
Does our PM considers himself first as our Prime Minister or the UMNO President???   

Nama 

christopher chuah

Alamat Elektronik 

christopher_1982@hotmail.com

Pendapat 

Pada pendapat saya,hak keistimewaan kaum Melayu,sudah lama dilaksanakan.Tujuan utama hak ini ialah membantu golongan Melayu,   akan tetapi sudah lama hak ini diwujudkan ,sudah tiba masanya kita menberi peluang kepada golongan ini untuk berdikari.Sudah   tentu bukannya segera hapuskan semua .Kita boleh hapuskan hak mereka sedikit demi sedikit.Dalam zaman alaf baru ini mereka perlu   berdikari.Kalau kita tidak menghapuskan hak ini sampai bila mereka akan berdikari.Hapuskan hak bukannya kita menbenci mereka malahan   kita ingin menolonh mereka.

Nama 

Chinese Malaysian

Alamat Elektronik 

Pendapat 

My identity -- Malaysian is the noun, Chinese is only the adjective.   
  
Saya rasa kita perlu bantu semua ank Malaysia, yang Melayu dan juga yang bukan Melayu, yang perlukan bantuan.   
  
Jangan kita mempunyai prasangka terhadap saudara-saudari kita yang berlainan kaum. Sukakah kita kalau kita yang diperkecilkan ?   
  
Biar kita berusaha mengkikis sentimen dan mentaliti angkuh yang mengutamakan kaum sendiri dan mengenepikan kaum lain, di hati kita sendiri.   
  
Atas cinta saya kepada tanahair dan semua anak-anaknya, saya menyokong 100 % Suqiu dan menyangkal mereka yang menfitnah !

Nama 

A True Malaysian

Alamat Elektronik 

Nil

Pendapat 

Dear Malaysian,   
A group of Malaysian expatriates and family members (about 100 persons) celebrated "Kerana Mu Malaysia" Merdeka Day in one of the hotel in Suzhou, China on Sept 1st 2000 because we are proud to be Malaysian. Wherever we are, Malaysia is our Home-Sweet-Home.   
The most talked about subject during the dinner was ; Why and How can our PM compared Suqiu with the armed religious fanatic and communist terrorist. How can our PM said such accusation in his Merdeka address to the nation ? Is he spoke as a Malaysia PM or as UMNO President ? We will understand him more if it is the later because he has political motives to portray UMNO as the champion of our Malay friends. We are very sad at our PM making use of this auspicious opportunity to gain political mileage fpr UMNO.   
  
My personal opinion, there is nothing in Suqiu's content that challenge the Special Right of the Bumiputra that is gurantee in our country constitution. I do not understand why this misunderstand cannot be solved by "consultation - the famous term used by BN" but to resort to demostration - (Special Right of UMNO youth) and wild accusation, while disregard the peace and stability of our beloved nation, Malaysia.   
  
Keep up the spirit, Suqiu ! We are with you !   
Suqiu Boleh ! Malaysia Boleh !

Nama 

Australia University Student

Alamat Elektronik 

tidak sesuai untuk dihebohkan

Pendapat 

Lama tidak membaca berita malaysia,tak sangka politikus-politikus malaysia masih tak matang seperti masa dulu.Amat mengkagumkan dan memalulan apabila menerima berita-berita seperti ini sempena merdeka and meyeberakkan berita-berita ini ke luar negara pada masa yang sama.   
  
Saya sangat setuju dengan penulisan dan kata-kata Fathi Aris Omar baru-baru ini.   
  
Bagi pihak saya, sebagai seorang pelajar university luar negeri ,pada pendapat saya seperti berikut :   
  
Segala pun telah menimbul dan belaku,ini bukan lah masa untuk mengaku atau mengkiritik kesalahan daripada sesiapa pihak.Memang menyedihkan bahawa Malaysia masih seperiti dahulu yang merupakan sebuah negara yang suka mengkritikan antara satu sama lain setelah berlaku sesuatu kes,dan ada pula yang melupakan merekalah yang menyisahkan perkara-perkara daripada prinsipnya.Ada pula yang selalu berpangkat tinggi tetapi bersikap seakan-akan kanak-kanak yang tidak matang and mengeluarkan kata-kata yang tidak menyeuaikan masa and tempat .Ada pula yang berpendidkan tinggi,tepati berlagak seperti orang gila yang hilang waras setelah dihasut oleh sesuatu pihak.Ada pula yang suka bercakap and berbicara pada bila-bila masa tetapi terus tutup mulut setelah berlaku sesuatu kejadian kerana takut bertanggungjawab.   
  
Malaysia merupakan sebuah negara yang aman dan damai,akan tetapi ia mempunyai bunyak orang yang berpendikan tinggi,berpendapat jauh,suka berbicara.Malangnya,apabila berlaku kejadian-kejadian,semuanya hanya tahu mengkritik antara satu sama lain and meminta antara satu sama lain untuk memaaf-maafan .Ada pula selalu menggunakan cara yang ketinggalan zaman untuk menutup and menjauhkan perhatian pada masalah yang sebenarya.   
  
Ini lah abad ke-21, menuju ke era baru,merealisasikan wawasan 2020.Ini lah masa untuk mengatasikan masalah-masalah di hadapan ,meningkatkan semangat,produktiviti,membukakan diri ke arah yang lebih besar untuk menyerap and menerima informasi,teknologi,cara hidup and ilmu pengetahuan yang baru.   
  
Ini bukan masanya untuk mencungilkan hal-hal yang ketinggalan masa untuk membesar-besarkan dan diketawa di dalam negara atau luar negara .Ini akanamat memalukan semua rakyat malaysia.   
  
Selain itu,sekaranglah masanya untuk menyelesaikan masalah yang sebenarnya,jangan menyusahkan media-media dan menyelewangkan masa untuk melapor kan "prosess-prosess" kejadian dan siapa yang bersalah .   
  
Harap rakyat malaysia dan pihak tertentu bersikat matang sikit.Sebenarnya,kebanyakkan kejadian yang berlaku di malaysia hanya dimainkan atau dilakukan oleh beberapa orang BERPANKGAT dan BERKUASA.Jangan main permainan ini lagi.Ini hanya membentukkan malaysia merupakan sebuah negara yang huru-hara antara kaum.Tetapi, ia hanya hura -hara antara beberapa orang yang BERPANKGAT dan BERKUASA sahaja.   
  
Sebagai seoramg pelajar university luar negara, kami amat bimbang malaysia apabila ia berlaku kes-kes politik,kaum yang bear semasa kita di luar negeri.Akan tetapi,sekali-kali,setelah kami menganalasikan bahawa kes-kes besar ini hanya dimainkan oleh orang yang yang sama yang tidak bermatang dan dibesar-besarkan lagipun menggunakan orang bawahnya untuk menyebarkan dan menyerakkan. Lagipun ,orang yang bermain and berkuasa di belakang selalu menghilangkan diri setelah berlaku kes-kes ini. Malangnya malaysia mempunyai pihak-pihak ini....   
  
Bagi keadaan sekarang,berita-berita dari aliran utama telah ditutupkan,kami yang di luar negara telah menghilangkan berita yang terkini.Marilah kawan, jangan menggunakan teknik ini untuk mengawal media.Kini ialah abad ke-21,informasi bebas and berbincangan bebas adalah hak "basic" kita.   
  
Yang pentingnya sekarang dan solusionya adalah seperti berikut :   
1.tunggu Pm balik.   
2.pihak Suqiu menjelaskan lagi dengan PM secepat PM balik.   
3.Rakyat harus menggunakan otak and mata sendiri untuk mengenalpastikan sesuatu betul and salah.   
4.pihak yang masih bermain-main and berbicara sampah,sila tutupkan mulut dan fikirkan cara menyelesaikan.   
5.membenarkan balik media untuk menyair kan kejadian yang 100% benar tetapi bukan hanya melaporkan "proses dan progress",siapa yang betul ,siapa yang salah ".   
  
Kepada rakyat Malaysia :   
Selesaikan masalah yang ketinggalan zaman,   
Memjejak kaki ke depan,   
Membantu pihak yang memelukan,   
Mengunakan otak untuk memastikan perkara yang benar,   
Menutup mulut untuk bercakap sampah,   
Menggunakan tangan untuk merealisasikan wawasan,   
Menggunakan cara yang matang untuk meyelesaikan .   
  
Akhir kata,sebenarnya, tiada kaum malayu, kaum cina, kaum india, bumibutra di malaysia. KIta hanya ada satu bangsa iaitu MALAYSIAN.Satu bangsa satu negara.   
  
Sila semua pihak menyelesaikan masalah secepat mungkin dan menghentikan memalukan melaysia in antaranagsa.   
  
Tibalah masa untuk meyelesai masalah bukan hanya bercakap besar.   
  
Semoga berjaya.   
  
*Kami adalah sekumpulan pelajar universiti di australia dan berkerja di media.Jika memelukan , kita boleh menghubungi dan mengadakan satu berbicara antara pelajar malaysia di unviversiti australia di radio stasten.Dan pihak malaysia boleh mendengarkan rancangan ini secara langsung dari WEB jika memelukan.   
  
Saya akan memaklumkan berita and suara kami dalam surat yang seterusnya.Terima kasih.

Nama 

Irwan

Alamat Elektronik 

irwanis@waumail.com

Pendapat 

First of all, thanks for reading.   
  
From my reading of the request by Suqiu, the major error that u guys/gals made is that,   no malay nor indian parties involved in making this 'resolutions'. And I do think, that   is why you are labeled 'communists' by our beloved(??) Prime Minister.   
  
I, as a malay do support your act and the 17 demands from Suqiu. Wish you all the best.   
If you do need me to appear in a meet, just mail me. I'll be sure to attend.

Nama 

SuQiu bermain kata-kata

Alamat Elektronik 

abc@xyz.com

Pendapat 

In my opinion, SuQiu just doing lobbying and word games here. The 17 demands clearly shows how small the intention given to basic humanity while bigger propotion actually given to get bigger Chinese interest while lessen Bumi's interest.   
  
Thus demands on subject like women's right, abolishment of certain Acts, uplifting of orang asli's status etc was done sooo lame that it actually looked like SuQiu just want to try to be seen as a hero but actually shows SuQiu's true colours.   
  
In a wider view, SuQiu had already give the chinese community a bad image. Other community will never trust anything that come from the chinese community because they will always be seen as having chinese personal interest, although with humanity elements thrown in.   
  
Thus, SuQiu has the responsibility not only to answer to the Malay community, but also to the Chinese community that they "betrayed".

Nama 

Seorang WARGANEGARA Malaysia

Alamat Elektronik 

Tidak diperlukan

Pendapat 

The fact remains that the Chinese in Malaysia have a longer business history then the other races. While the Malays were busy plucking coconuts (maybe they have not found a way of teaching thr monkeys to climb coconut trees yet!), the Chinese were sweating it out in every corner of this country trying to open-up rubber plantations, tin mines, etc with the hope that they could "save" enough for their next generation. The Chinese by nature works hard and for every dollar earned they will put aside enough for the future. Same goes for the Indians especially the "Chettiars". Thrifty was the motto. There is therefore no wonder that the hardworking and honest Chinese soon became the economic backbone of this nation. From the time of Princess Hang Li Po, the Chinese were merchants.Their business grew because their children would inherit the business and continue passing them on to the next generation. Whatever was made during one generation would be inherited by the next and so on and so forth. Over time, the   the chinese became so much richer by comparisons with the other races. Imagine a marathon runner having the advantage of starting 400-500 years before the other runners. Unfortunately, the Government thought they could simply correct the imbalance overnight by giving the malays special rights. Putting 30% of one race's wealth into another race's pocket just won't do the job. It would just be sheer waste to see the efforts of generations of these hardworking and honest chinese simply given to another person hoping that he will know what to do with it. The chinese are forever wary of a child whom just spend away his father's wealth (we call him "bai ka cai"). We always hear these government selected few complain that the "capital" given to them is insufficient. They always want more. No wonder the chinese are saying that enough is enough. Our beloved PM asked the chinese to help the malays. Isn't taking away the "tongkat" helping them??? Remember the almighty word "BERDIKARI???" (Our previous DPM Tun Gaffar   
Baba used to say the same thing before ... I am only using his exact words). I am sure after a few generations more there will be malays we can be proud of. But until then, respect the other malaysians too. We too are born in this country we call our home. By all means give the malays a helping hand but don't spoil them. They say, spare the rod and spoil the child. It is not easy to one day sell "satay" and the next trying to sell "whatever". So for the sake of this nation "Keranamu Malaysia" .... wise up, everybody. One word of caution to all extremist out there, whatever you call yourself by, do not attempt to destroy this multi racial society. We are all here to stay, like it or not. Take Heed!!! Beware!!!

Nama 

Goh GH

Alamat Elektronik 

gohgh@usa.net

Pendapat 

Great work! Well done. Your appeal is the only hope for millions of non-bumi Malaysians. You have done the right thing. You are correct ethically, and morally. Keep it up, I am behind you, and so do millions others.

 

 

 

 

 

Nama 

Kevin Tan

Alamat Elektronik 

garpeng@hotmail.com

Pendapat 

As a Malaysian professional working abroad, I applaud the stand you make which truely reflect the sentiment of all Malaysians and those who preferred to live in exile overseas due to dissatisfaction of the political situation in Malaysia.   
  
If our political representive to the like of MCA, MIC and UMNO is not listening to the Rakyat at large of the need to keep abreast to recent social, economic and political developement, how would the nation move forward in the atmosphere of peace and prosperity.   
  
Suqiu 17-Points represent the timely wake up call for those politically complacent to come forth and bring this nation to political maturity by listening and accepting the opinion of others eventhough it is not in line with the governing party.   
  
Malaysia is beseized with racial discrimation for too long and has not been in keeping with the global demand to rid prejudice against any particular race. Equality, wealth sharing, harmony and equal opportunity for growth is now the order of the political arena today.   
  
Let not forget politicians are people elected by the people and for the people in a democratic country. Let's exercise our democratic right wisely.   

Nama 

mat rock

Alamat Elektronik 

mana ada

Pendapat 

Fathi Aris, Azrin Zainal, Mohd Nasir Hashim, Nik Aziz dan lain-lain. Inilah orang Melayu yang sebenarnya. Yang lain hanya bertopengkan manusia dengan bernamakan "Melayu". Gua caya sama lu! Are you ready to rock Bee Ant like a hurricane? It's show time.

Nama 

simon kwan

Alamat Elektronik 

stsim@lycos.com

Pendapat 

The 17 points election appeal has been a hot issue. Unfortunately, I do not have the full text of this appeal. Would you be kind enough to e-mail this 17 points election appeal to me?   
Thahk you and best of luck.

Nama 

melayu lama

 

Alamat Elektronik 

takdo

 

Pendapat 

banci terbaru   
Bumiputra 67%   
  
Baguslah tu! Semakin ramai yang akan menyokong parti Barisan Alternatif. Semakin ramai yang akan meninggalkan parti BN yang sudah tidak relevan lagi. Kah! Kah! Kah!

 

Nama 

oghang cina

Alamat Elektronik 

tadak

Pendapat 

Ucapan PM Malaysia sempena hari kemerdekaan yang ke 43 sememangnya mengancam dan mengkagumkan. Memang bagus. Kata-kata PM telah menyedarkan khususnya orang cina yang masih berada dalam lamunan. Kami telah sedar dan bangkit dari lamunan kami. Terima kasih PM. Ucapan PM telah membuka mata kami. Ia telah mengingatkan kami siapa BN sebenarnya. Kami sudah tentu tahu apa yang harus kami lakukan pada pilihan raya umum pada masa hadapan. Usahlah kami ingin memberitahu kepada PM apa hasrat kami. PM sendiri lebih mengetahuinya. Tepuk dada tanya selera. Ayuh orang Cina, sudah tiba masanya kebangkitan untuk bebas dalam erti kata sebenarnya, bebas benar-benar bebas sepenuhnya telah bermula. Api kebangkitan akan kami pelihara dengan sebaik-baiknya sehingga pilihan raya bermula. Sekali lagi saya bagi pihak orang Cina ingin mengucapkan terima kasih kepada PM.

 

Nama 

A Malaysian Student

 

Alamat Elektronik 

lonewolf313@waumail.com.my

 

Pendapat 

I only got to know what really was Suqiu from Malaysiakini.com and this website, and from what i have read from the 17 requests made to the government, do i really know what is requested. I would say that the request made is very rational and came at the right moment and i also agree with what the committee is fighting for - fairness above all else.   
As a student, a non-bumiputera student, i entirely agree to the removal of the racial quota in our country's education system, especially the racial quota of students in institutes of higher learning.   
Many though not all bright students in Malaysia are not given ample and fair opportunity to pursue the fields they have keen interest in. On the other hand, many were being rejected in or only offered other courses because of the racial quota. This is true as my own sister's old schoolmate, a malay girl, was offered entry to study medicine even though she only scored moderately in the SPM, whereas my sis scored 7 distinctions out of 10 subjects but couldn't get into any of the public universities in Malaysia.My sis's good friend, a non-bumi, scored 3 A's in STPM and still can't get into a university and had to settle with a diploma course. This is what's wrong with the education system!   
Ask any man or woman on the street which doctor would they normally choose to visit, a malay or non-malay, and the answer would normally be a non-malay doctor. Why ? It's because a Malay (a Bumiputera) can be a doctor quite "easily"- meaning that they don't need high qualifications to study medicine. Non-malays who get to be doctors are most likely very bright students. Thus, this not only hurt the really good malay doctors (which i don't deny there are many of them)as they would be classed as "lousy" doctors.   
My respect for our Prime Minister, Dr. Mahathir, was shattered when he associated Suqiu with Al Ma'unah. This is the utmost outrageous thing i've heard from the PM. How can Suqiu be related to the group of extremists as Suqiu ask for the protection of human rights whereas Al Ma'unah killed people in cold blood!   
So, i find that Suqiu is relevant to realising PM's Vision 2020-towards a united and prosperous nation.

 

 

Nama 

Suqiuying Malaysian

 

Alamat Elektronik 

 

Pendapat 

Let's set up more websites for Suqiu promoting the other 16 points, so that any conspiracy to continue play on the Malay rights issue will not succeed.   
  
I read the article "PM smepitkan reformasi Suqiu" (http://www.suqiu.org/news_malaysiakini_02092000.htm) on Malaysiakini and agree the author Mr Fathi Aris Omar's view.   
  
I believe there are many Malay friends who would understand Suqiu like Mr Fathi Aris and Mr Azrin Zainal (http://www.malaysiakini.com/archives_letters/2000/sept/sept2-3/letter2.htm). But Suqiu must reach out.   
  
If only more Malay Malaysians know that Suqiu is also fighting against ISA, and for Judiciary's independence, fair media, etc; they would definitely support Suqiu and understand Malay Rights is a non-issue here.   
  
I wonder what is Suqiu's response to Mr Fathi Aris's call. I noticed that Suqiu has been taking a very low profile that she doesn't defend herself. While we can understand the dilemma of Suqiu (worrying that it will be used by irresponsible media and politicians as another excuse for attacks), I think we the supporters of Suqiu must do some constructive things.   
  
Setting up agenda-themed unofficial websites would be important. Imagine if we have 16 unofficial websites on all the other issues. Imagine when someone search for Suqiu on yahoo, and he/she find a lot of websites related to Suqiu but related to different topics : women, workers, educations, privatisation, housing, orang asli ... Do you think he/she would believe that Suqiu is a Chinese extremist things ?   
  
Can anyone do this for Suqiu ? We need actions. I don't know about IT. But I will get my IT-savvy friends to help. I believe Suqiu websites need to bossoms like the Reformasi one.   
  
If you agree with me, please share with us more ideas on how these websites should be.   
  
But I think there is a few important things we should know :   
(1) the website must be in BM or English other than Chinese. Please give proirity to BM too.   
(2) We should quote the relevant appeal of Suqiu (No. X.X) in our websites so that where people will see with their eyes the contents of Suqiu.   
(3) we need to state it clear that "the website is set up by volunteers and not affliated with the Suqiu Committee, to save them from any possible trouble. I visited the asiaco.forum/suqiu and found that, despite the good intention, the name of the website is misleading. People may think that it has the authorisation of Suqiu. In such a situation, some quarters may find faults and attribute to Suqiu Committee. We have to really be careful.   
  
Dear Webmaster,   
  
You do a fantastic work to keep us updated with Suqiu development. Wonder if it is possible that you provide a facility where we can post links of websites according to the issues (17 points /33 classification /83 points, whatever you like) so that the idea I suggest can be done.   
  
Thanks for the great jobs. I believe every visitor here will introduce more visitors. Thanks !   
  

 

 

Nama 

New Supporters for Suqiu

 

Alamat Elektronik 

 

Pendapat 

We would like to congratulate Suqiu for quickly becoming the most well respected and supported organisation by all Malaysian Chinese. We strongly believe that your appeals are universal principles for the betterment of all races in the new Malaysia.   
  

 

 

Nama 

Awaken Malaysian

 

Alamat Elektronik 

 

Pendapat 

To: Melayu Baru   
  
I agree we him that neither the Malaysian Chinese nor Suqiu is in the position to change the constitution which will protect the Malay's special rights based on the population statistics. In actual fact, it was never the intention of Suqiu to question the special rights of the Malays.   
Suqiu is a Committee which had merely presented an "appeal" on behalf of the members, representing the views of their respective organisations, to all political parties for their consideration during the election.The meaning of the word "appeal" is to make a "request". If the PM and UMNO do not agree with the appeal made by Suqiu, they could have just say "no" to it. Neither Suqiu nor the Chinese in Malaysia, which comprises only 27% of the population, can do anything about it.   
The interesting part is that the BN has accepted the "appeal" BEFORE the election and accused the committee of making a radical demand AFTER the election.The even more interesting episode of the whole saga is that instead of trying to tone down the issue,the PM has chosen to augment the ordeal to a higher level in his speech causing further racial disharmony among the different races. In view of the longer term benefit for all races in Malaysia, I hope that the Chairman of Suqiu will dissolve the Committee so that it will not be used by others as an instrument to garner support for their own political agenda. In the next election, many of us will remember to vote for an honest party that will honour its commitment during the election period.   
  

 

 

Nama 

PHANG JUINN SYONG

 

Alamat Elektronik 

louis_phang@yahoo.com.tw

 

Pendapat 

suqiu is a very good ideal, Please keep it on

 

 

Nama 

 

Alamat Elektronik 

 

Pendapat 

kepada: semua AJK "Suqiu"   
  
kerajaan dipilih oleh semua rakyat, maka, jika PM(kerajaan)membuat sesuatu pernyataan yang bercanggah dengan kehendak rakyat, bukan Boss(rakyat) yang meminta untuk berjumpa dengan pekerja(PM)untuk membuat penjelasan, sebaliknya PM yang seharusnya datang berjumpa dengan Bossnya. sila jangan bertunduk kepada politikus dan diktator yang sentiasa mempergunakan kuasa. terima kasih.

 

 

Nama 

malaysian

 

Alamat Elektronik 

@com

 

Pendapat 

To suqiu committee,   
  
we all malaysian strongly support the stand taken by suqiu.

 

 

Nama 

BONIFACE

 

Alamat Elektronik 

BONIFACECCV@HOTMAIL.COM

 

Pendapat 

To Melayu Baru,   
  
Sir,please don't try to play the percentage game here.If you are truly a good Malaysian,you should not judge the percentage of races in the country, we are not going to war here( the biggest group will win the battle!)hey, please don't make us laugh. We are all Malaysians and we care for her future development.Most of the younger Malaysians,not only Malays but Indians and Chinese, they born in this country and they will love this country more than any other place in the world.This is because Malaysia is also their home and a place to bring up their next generations.So, Malays, Chinese and Indians are all Malaysians.   
  
To Suqiu,   
Keep up the good works and good luck to you for the talk with the PM.We Malaysians are always there to support you.   

 

 

Nama 

anak malaysia 2

 

Alamat Elektronik 

Former bn supporter

 

Pendapat 

 what is going on with our PM ???????   
  
Saya masih ingat , sebelum pilihanraya mereka setuju dengan rayuan SUQIU  tapi apa balasannya ?? balasan untuk kita, fitnah daripada BN & our PM   yang mengatakan AJK SUQIU = Komunis atau Kumpulan ajaran sesat   
  
saya sangat KECEWA dengan ucapan DIA adakah dia sudah baca and  memahami SUQIU ???????????   
walaupun saya berbangsa cina, tapi saya bersetuju dengan pemimpin   PAS ,Tok Guru Nik Aziz ,Beliau berkata: " persoalan pokok di sini bukanlah kaum, tetapi kemiskinan. Siapa yang miskin,   maka siapa harus diberi bantuan. Suqiu sememangnya tidak menyentuh Hak Keistimewaan Orang Melayu . "   
  
so, Kawan-kawanku yang cintakan Negara MALAYSIA sila tunjukkan apa yang sebenar terkandung dalam kertas SUQIU  kepada kawan-kawan yang berlainan bangsa..AGAR   sesetengah puak "ekstremis" yang suka memain-mainkan isu perkauman  TIDAK AKAN BERJAYA .   sila beritahu mereka SUQIU adalah untuk semua kaum di MALAYSIA dan bukanlah untuk satu kaum sahaja .   
BN masih ada 4 tahun lagi untuk menentukan masa depan mereka .   
  
## ###{######## ####### ###########} ### # # ####### ??????????   

 

 

Nama 

Melayu Baru

 

Alamat Elektronik 

tiada

 

Pendapat 

Orang Cina jangan harap untuk menghapuskan hak istimewa   orang Melayu. Peratusan orang Cina di Malaysia hanyalah  24.6% mengikut bancian yang terbaru. Berbanding dengan kaum   Bumiputra yang berjumlah 67%. Pada tahun 1990 peratusan orang cina adalah 27%. Pada awal 80'an pula bilangannya  adalah 32%. Dengan purata penurunan populasi kaum cina   sebanyak 3%-5% dalam masa 10 tahun. Adalah dijangkakan bilangan orang cina akan menjadi hanya kira-kira 15%-20% sahaja pada tahun 2020.   Untuk menghapuskan hak istimewa orang melayu parlimen perlu   mendapatkan sokongan majoriti 2/3 ahli parlimen. Oleh itu   orang-orang Melayu janganlah bimbang. Orang Cina memang   tidak berkeupayaan untuk meminda perlembagaan. Hanya orang   melayu yang berkeupayaan untuk memindanya.

 

 

Nama 

S

 

Alamat Elektronik 

 

Pendapat 

Suqiu akan bertegakkan pendirian yang terus dan tidak berputus asa walaupun diancam kejam  !   
Suqiu bukan berbelah kepada kaum tertentu juga bukan untuk  menyokong ataupun menyebelahi parti tertentu.   
  
pls, Pm..jangan memainkan isu perkauman untuk mengailkan sokongan dengan cara ketiggalan zaman.We r in 21 century man, be rational .Saya amat kesal sekali bila mendengar speech daripada seorang pemimpin kerajaan tapi wataknya seolah-olah pemimpin sebuah parti yang menekankan perkauman, padahal, Suqiu sedikit langsung tidak menyentuh hati orang Melayu,seperti yang termaktub dalam perlembagaan.   
Tetapi apa yang berlaku selama 43 tahun,Kerajaan kononnya dipilih melalui proses demokrasi,semakin tidak menyanjungi   hak-hak asasi rakyat Malaysia,yang mempelihara warga Malaysia.   
  
Pada pandangan saya pada masa yang amat sulit(critical) ini, Suqiu akan menghadapi kebebasan bersuara,sila lihat apa yang dilaporkan dalam akbar Melayu bahkan Inggeris lansung tak menyentuh apa yang diberi keterangan daripada Suqiu.   
Akhir sekali, harap-harap pengaorbanan yang perlu jika ia terpaksa berlaku Suqiu akan membawa cahaya kemerdekaan keranamu Malaysia.

 

Nama 

New Opposition Member

 

Alamat Elektronik 

 

Pendapat 

We strongly support the stand taken by Suqiu and hope that the PM will continue with his bias allegations which will only encourage more BN supporters to vote for the opposition.

 

Nama 

A Student from UK

 

Alamat Elektronik 

ccs@soton.ac.uk

 

Pendapat 

It is usual to have a lots of misunderstandings, obstacles and criticisms while we were trying to make a big change.   
I am sure all the commitee members of Su Qiu understand that. We may have been disappointed and shocked by the statements made by our PM, but we are certainly not defeated.   
I hope you will keep carrying out your duty as usual until we achieve the LONG TERM GOAL i.e. to create an 'Equal Malaysia'.   
  
You have made the right decision to request a meeting with the PM to explain to him what excatly it is about the appeals. We do not want confrontations but rational discussions and negotiations.   
It is not only to explain to the PM or UMNO, the target should be all malaysians, I mean every malaysians, what is the appeals about.   
  
Also, we also have to tell all bumiputras that ' Kami bukan pendatang asing'. We are staying under the same roof and we do not contribute less than any of you do to the country.   
We just want every poor malaysian regardless of their race, religion and sex to benefit from the government assistance.   
This is not an appeal from the chinese community. It is an appeal from all the malaysians who want to see no body is suffering from unfair treatments just because they are not bumiputra although they are malaysians.   
  
Good luck!   

 

 

Nama 

BONIFACE

 

Alamat Elektronik 

bonifaceccv@hotmail.com

 

Pendapat 

After I've read today's newspaper,I felt sad to learn that our Malaysia No.1 man was not sensible at all.He should see things at all angles.Suqiu didn't do anything wrong but instead got the blame from him, this is totally unfair.   
Anyway, we Malaysians are always there to support you,Suqiu.   
Keep up the good works!

 

 

Nama 

KY Wong

 

Alamat Elektronik 

wky_kl@yahoo.com

 

Pendapat 

To Suqiu Committee,   
  
Good job, well done. We 100% stand behind you on the 17 appeals. Be tactful, don't fall into those selfish politician's traps.   
  
To Chinese,   
  
Work harder as what our grandparents did.

 

 

Nama 

Mohd Nasir Hashim

 

Alamat Elektronik 

 

Pendapat 

Hak istimewa ikat rakyat-kerajaan   
Mohd Nasir Hashim   
  
Mungkin juga amalan itu berlaku secara sengaja kerana budaya pautan menguntungkan pemimpin politik yang memerintah kerana rakyat makin terhutang budi kepada mereka.   
  
Mereka akan menyindir, menegur, mengugut dan mengutuk golongan tertentu agar rakyat sentiasa diingat-ingatkan bahawa bantuan yang diterima itu adalah ehsan daripada pemimpin politik yang memerintah.   
  
Justeru itu rakyat patut memilih mereka sebagai calon dalam pilihan raya demi pilihan raya nanti. Dengan cara ini kedudukan mereka tetap terjamin.   
  
Akibat hak keistimewaan yang diperolehi, kaum Melayu sentiasa dilalikan dengan keseronokan, harapan atau keyakinan yang palsu - seolah-olah mereka sudah diberikan perlindungan mutlak.   
  
Kalau kita kaji kembali masalah-masalah yang berlaku seperti masalah peneroka bandar yang memerlukan rumah; masalah pekerja yang ditindas oleh majikan atau kaum pemodal; harga barangan yang melambung tinggi; atau masalah dadah, maka kita boleh merumuskan hak keistimewaan Melayu memang samar-samar atau tidak wujud walau ramai pemimpin Melayu menganggotai Dewan Rakyat dan dewan-dewan undangan negeri.   
  
Tetapi gejala penindasan dan eksploitasi bukan hanya di kalangan Melayu, kaum-kaum lain juga menderita akibat dari masalah yang disebutkan tadi.   
  
Jelasnya, isu yang penting berbangkit di sini bukanlah hak Bumiputera atau ketuanan Melayu tetapi cara kaum pemodal-pemerintah mengekalkan dan membolot keuntungan, kuasa dan pengaruh kumpulan atau individu tertentu.   
  
Tanyalah kepada golongan Melayu, malah kaum-kaum lain, yang miskin sama ada pemimpin politik mereka sanggup berjuang habis-habisan untuk mempertahankan hak mereka. Jawapannya jelas, mereka tidak sanggup jika tidak mendapat pulangan tertentu.   
  
Pelbagai keturunan Melayu   
  
Penggunaan istilah-istilah Melayu' dan Bumiputera' juga membingungkan. Soalnya, tidak seorang pun yang berani menggelarkan dirinya sebagai Melayu atau Bumiputera tulen kerana kaum pedalaman dan Orang Asli lebih layak lagi menerima gelaran ini.   
  
Sebenarnya kaum Melayu yang ada sekarang berasal daripada keturunan kaum Arab, India, Cina, Indonesia, Thailand dan kawasan serantau. Mereka dianggap Melayu sekiranya mengamalkan budaya Melayu dan menganut Islam.   
  
Oleh itu, mengapa kita harus bertegang urat dan mencaci satu kaum dengan kaum yang lain? Bukankah ini bermakna mencaci dan mencemar keturunan nenek moyang sendiri? Kita sepatutnya berbangga dengan keturunan kita daripada berbagai-bagai kaum dan berusaha menyatukan semua.   
  
Sebenarnya ketuanan Melayu yang didewa-dewakan itu pernah diserang dan dipatah-patahkan semasa berlakunya krisis Perlembagaan - martabat, hak dan kekebalan Raja-raja Melayu diperkecilkan di bawah pentadbiran Perdana Menteri Dr. Mahathir Mohamad.   
  
Pada waktu itu, golongan cerdik pandai dan parti politik berganding bahu mengutuk golongan istana dan kaum kerabat ini. Apabila kedudukan sultan yang melambangkan perpaduan dan ketuanan Melayu dipertikai, maka konsep itu sudah tercabar, makin lemah dan kemudiannya menjadi sumbang.   
'Umno-putera'   
  
Kini, melalui pengagihan projek dan persaingan pengaruh dalam parti-parti kerajaan, khususnya Umno, pemimpin politik yang memerintah secara sedar atau tidak berjaya mendefinisikan semula konsep Bumiputera dan menjadikannya "Umno-putera."   
  
Segelintir pemimpin dan aktivis Umno mendapat pelbagai keistimewaan, sementara orang Melayu umumnya mendapat serpihan keistimewaan sahaja. Mereka sentiasa dekat dengan pucuk pimpinan parti dan kaum pemodal Umno untuk meraih keuntungan yang paling besar.   
  
  
Bahagian akhir esok: Membuka episod perkauman 1987?   
Bahagian 1: Hak Melayu jatuhkan martabat bangsa?   
  
  
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------   
Dr. MOHD NASIR HASHIM merupakan Pengerusi, Parti Sosialis Malaysia (PSM), kini parti itu dalam proses mengambil tindakan undang-undang terhadap kerajaan kerana gagal meluluskan pendaftarannya. Beliau merupakan aktivis masyarakat dan pernah berkhidmat sebagai pensyarah kanan di Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia (UKM).   

 

 

 

 

Nama 

webcitizen

Alamat Elektronik 

webcitizen@hotmail.com

Pendapat 

Suqiu,   
Next time pls involve BA in drafting the appeal.   
Have U read PM merdeka speech ??   
I fall from my chair when I read it !!   
  
If U want the appeal to be 100% acceptable by all races   
I suggest that U ammend point no 7 that said "Relinquish   the racial-based quota system for university admission."   
This request is not acceptable by our malay brother.   Instead replace it with "Build more quota free public   University"   
  
webcitizen   

Nama 

A True Malaysian

Alamat Elektronik 

Pendapat 

It is obvious to all of us that the PM is trying to make use of Suqiu as a scapegoat to garner the diminishing support of the Malays. His attempt to invoke the wrong feelings among the Malays will only alienate strong supporter of the Barrisan National like me to vote for the opposition in the next election. I would like to urge all members of the Committee to remain calm and not to provide them with further opportunity to play the "racial card".   
Lastly, I would like to let the committee members know that we are behind you all the way.

Nama 

Meng

Alamat Elektronik 

Pendapat 

I am disgusted at the way UMNO youth behave. Supporting UMNO, is it worth it??. I have lost confidence in the BN, comes the next general election they will loose my vote and from my whole clan. You chinese out there think.

Nama 

Ning dr P.Pinang

Alamat Elektronik 

qfting@crosswinds.net

Pendapat 

Merdeka! Merdeka! Merdeka.........   
Apa gunanya laungan kuat ini sekiranya kita masih dijajah ?   
Dijajah? Ya, dijajah! Dijajah kerajaan yang tidak mengkotakan   janjinya!   
J/K Suqiu mengeluarkan rayuan demi manfaat semua warga M'sia,   tetapi apakah balasannya?   
Balasannya, fitnah daripada Mahathir.   Wahai rakyat M'sia yang tercinta, sedarlah, bangunlah,   jangan terperdaya oleh taktik kotor UMNO. Biarlah kita   semua berganding bahu, membina satu negara yang adil, bebas, dan makmur.     

Nama 

Alamat Elektronik 

Pendapat 

Kpada semua AJK "suqiu":   
  
saya berasa AJK suqiu tidak perlu menjawab segala kenyataan yang dibuat oleh politikus-politikus yang ekstrim dan berunsur mengancam. Kita harus menumpukan perhatian kepada pendapat dan kenyataan yang kontruktif dan bernas. misalnya pendapat yang disyorkan MB Kelantan, YB Datuk Tok Guru Nik Aziz yang jelas selaras dengan pendapat dan harapan kebanyakan warganegara Malaysia dan semangat "Suqiu", maka kita harus menjemput orang yang berfikiran terbuka seperti ini untuk membincangkan bagaimana kita orang Malaysia dapat merealisasikan harapan-harapan yang terpapar di dalam "suqiu". dengan seikhlas-ikhlas hati memohon. terima kasih.   

Nama 

Ali Genah

Alamat Elektronik 

null

Pendapat 

dear all Malaysians,   
Saya seorang warganegara dari Sarawak, bumi Kenyalang. I have been to many places and seen many cultures. Problems like poorness and social development are transcendent in all races. In the past(as what has been depicted in History textbooks) it has been highlighted that Malays are very poor and live in kampungs and earn very little money. But, don't forget, Chinese and Indians who came to our country many years ago also come almost empty-handedly. They have struggled so much to obtain a decent salary to lead a comfortable life. They have learnt that they have to work hard and struggle for themselves and they can't depend on the rest to help them. As what we have learnt, Chinese built their own schools independently from the government.   
Malays, as the main race, in the other hand, have been pampered by the British government (especially those in power) so that they will continue to support the government and not create any trouble for the British. Indians are sadly neglected for their weak political prowess due to their economic situation and number.   
I'm suspicious that the agreement made by our forefathers of different races might not reflect what the people have wanted. The Chinese and Indian leaders, were very financially well-off and would have not mind the concession made by them then. In our society, there are still many poor people regardless of race who need assistance from the goverment. Think about it, if there are two poor neighbours living near the forest, but one get chance to go for FELDA scheme, but the other does not just because of the race factor. Are we that inhumane enough to discriminate people on the basis of their skin colour!!??   
Actually, in my personal opinion, the bumiputera privileges only benefit a certain group of people. Look at the tenders offered by goverment agencies. Only those certain companies will successfully get them. They use this race sentiment to ensure that their 'periuk emas' not affected. They hope that the majority (Malays) will be happy with this few benefits while themselves mengaut keuntungan.   
if the scheme is continued, Malays will never learn to be independent, and they will tend to be complacent with their lives. just look at the results of the Malay students. They never need to work hard because they are always assured of scholarships and university placements. If this trend goes on, the name of Malays will be blemished as everyone in the world will be looking down on Malays whenever they go. It will soon come to a time when the Malays are only prominent in politics as they have no capabilities and no chance to really learn through natural competition in other areas such as education and business.   
  
WOULD YOU BE PROUD TO BE CALLED A MALAY THEN??   
  
God loves all of us humans, regardless of skin colour and grant us this beautiful place called Earth so we will share among us wisely. God Bless Those Who Fight For the DownTrodden and Weak.

Nama 

Alamat Elektronik 

qming@hotmail.com

Pendapat 

kepada Dato' Ong Ti Kiat(Ketua Pemuda MCA):   
  
Dato' mengatakan bahawa "Suqiu" tidak mewakili semua kaum Cina, ini bermakna MCA juga tidak mewakili semua kaum Cina. maka, jangan sekali-sekala mengatakan bahawa MCA mewakili kaum Cina. Sebenarnya, "Suqiu" tidak pernah menekankan bahawa ia mewakili sesuatu kaum malahan ia sentiasanya menekankan bahawa ia merupakan tuntutan demi semua kaum, jadi, sila jangan mempergunakan "suqiu" untuk menaikkan kedudukan sendiri dalam masyarakat melayu atas isu ini. Terima kasih!

Nama 

DC

Alamat Elektronik 

Ex-BN supporter

Pendapat 

I read with amusement of the Umno Youth demo against Suqiu.   
All the hoo-ha about representing for malay rights.   
  
If Umno Youth really and sincerly care for the malays,   
then they should increase the oil royalty for Trengannu, and not try to reduce it as reported in the media. After all the population of Trengannu is majority poor malays. There is no need to take to the street to show the whole world that you are fighting special malay rights. It will only prove that PAS was right in saying the whole episode is just a sandiwara.   
  
Umno Youth should fight in parliment for an increase in royalty for the poor malays in Trengannu and then the masses will believe that they are sincere.   
That they are not just fighting for Umnoputras...   
  
Otherwise, I think Unmo Youth is using Suqiu as a scrap-goat to regain political votes.   
  
DC

Nama 

Chin Keng Poh

Alamat Elektronik 

chintai@pd.jaring.my

Pendapat 

The Suqiu Committee MUST NOT apologize to Pemuda Umno or withdraw/review the 17-point Suqiu for reasons below:-
  
1. It does not touch on the Special rights of Malays.   
2. It has been accepted by the Cabinet.   
3. PM Datuk Seri Dr. Mahathir Mohamad has accepted Datuk David Chua's explanation.   

Nama 

chin wei

Alamat Elektronik 

chinweiong@hotmail.com

Pendapat 

Saya adalah bangsa cina.Walaupin saya cinta kepada bangsa kita,tetapi saya lebih cinta kepada negara kita.Sebenarnya,saya rasa suqiu 1 iaitu membantu orang yang miskin dan tidak mengira keturunan adalah baik dan adalah munasabah.Saya menyokong.Tetapi masalah kini ialah orang melayu mengatakn bahawa suqiu ini telah mempersoalkan hak keistimewaan orang melayu.Jika kamu tanya adakah tuduhan ini betul?Sebagai orang tepi yang tidak menyebelahi mana-mana pihak,saya rasa ini sebenarnya telah menyinggugkan perasaan orang melayu.Seperti suqiu 1 iaitu mengalakkan perpaduan negara dengan "mengambil langkah untuk memansuhkan perbezaan antara "bumiputera/bukan bumiputera dalam semua bidang",dengan kata lain,iaitu menghapuskan hak keistimewaan orang melayu.Selain itu,lagi ada suqiu 5 dan 7 juga adalah sama.Walaupun cadangan tersebut adalah berasaskan kebaikan semua rakyat malaysia,tetapi bagi orang melayu,mereka akan rasa kamu adalah cuba mempersoalkan hak keistimewaan mereka.Sebagai satu contoh,jika mereka kata mahu membina sekolah wawasan.Sekolah wawasan adalah bertujuan baik iaitu untuk mewujudkan perpaduan antara pelbagai kaum,tetapi bagi orang cina,kami akan merasakan perbuatan mereka adalah bertujuan untuk menghapuskan sekolah cina dan pemelajaran bahasa cina.Ini adalah sama dengan masalah tadi yang saya katakan.Oleh itu,tindakan pemuda umno walaupun tidak betul,tetapi mereka bukan sengaja,ini adalah kerana suqiu kami telah mengancam kedudukan mereka."Rayuan pilihanraya persatuan-persatuan cina malaysia"telah mengatakan bahawa tujuan suqiu ini adalah untuk kebaikan semua kaum.Tetapi sama ada tujuan ini adalah seperti yang dikatakan oleh "rayuan pilihanraya persatuan-persatuan cina malaysia" iaitu tujuan yang berasaskan kebaikan semua kaum atau ada tujuan yang sebaliknya,suqiu ini tetap telah mempersoalkan hak keistimewaan orang melayu seperti yang dikatakan oleh saya tadi di atas.Masalah belum selesai lagi,pemuda umno mahu kami minta maaf tetapi kita tidak mahu.Walaupun suqiu ini adalah telah menyinggungkan perasaan orang melayu,tetapi kita adalah tidak sengaja dan atas keinginan kita untuk mendapatkan keadilan dalam pelbagai bidang.Saya tahu kedua-dua pihak juga tidak mahu mengalah.Ini adalah kerana jika mana-mana pihak antara kedua-dua pihak ini mengalah,maka pihak yang mengalah itu mungkin akan"dibuli" lagi dalam bidang.Sebagai contoh,jika persatuan-persatuan cina mengalah,kesan buruk pertama suqiu ini tidak dapat dijadikan suqiu lagi.Selain itu,banyak kesan buruk lagi akan muncul lagi seperti jika kami mengalah,apabila kita menuntut apa pun juga susah seperti ingin membina sekolah cina juga susah kerana mereka telah menganggap kami sebagai persatuan yang pendiriannya tidak kukuh.Pada masa yang akan datang,"modal politik"kami iaitu orang cina juga akan dikurangkan.Untuk menyelesaikan masalah ini,kami(persatuan cina)boleh meminta maaf secara bukan rasmi dan pendirian kami tetap tidak berubah iaitu suqiu tetap adalah suqiu dan tidak akan dikembalikan dan di samping itu,kami juga akan meminta pemuda umno meminta maaf kepada persatuan cina atas tindakan pemuda umno pada hari lepas itu.Saya berharap masalah ini boleh diselesaikan dan perpaduan rakyat malaysia akan dikekalkan."Selamat Menyambut Hari Kemerdekaan".

Nama 

chong yi

Alamat Elektronik 

Pendapat 

Kelakuan P.UMNO harus dipertimbangkan oleh semua rakyat malaysia ,tidak kira kaum MELAYU,CINA,INDIA atau lain-lain.Kerana maksud yang suqiu terangkan,bukan apa yang dikatakan oleh P.UMNO. Oleh itu pihak jawatankuasa suqiu tidak perlu menbuat unduran terhadap mereka yang berniat lain. Demi KEADILAN ,KEAMANAN negara.Saya dan keluarga 100% sokong kepada jawatankuasa suqiu !! SEMOGA BERJAYA!!!

Nama 

protectionist

Alamat Elektronik 

ktteokt@pc.jaring.my

Pendapat 

i am of the opinion that being "over-protective" only do more harm than good. i cannot imagine having a kid who after 43 years of given opportunities, today still turns to "its father" for "aid, protection and charity". 43 years of "independence" bears no meaning at all in this context. being independent would from my point of view, mean that we are to stand on our own feet and be self-sufficient, face society as an independent entity and not seek such "immatured" measures. if my kid was to be like that, i would very much be ashamed to face the world and when someone brings up this subject, i will not know where to hide my face. but instead these people do not feel the least bit shy at all at such allegations (which are in fact true) and still talk back in such an uncivilized manner. as a rational being, man ought to know when limits have been reached. chances have been offered to such people, opportunities given, aid in the form of money and other provided but still there is no improvement in their standard of living. all these boils down to one single problem, i.e. their way of life and attitude in life. they are too easily satisfied in a way, with their achievements and should they not achieve what is expected, they can always turn back to their "father" for aid. this is equivalent to a father "pampering and spoiling" his own kid. the kid has never been given a chance to stand up and walk on his own, instead he has always been provided with a "baby walker". just how long can this "baby walker" last? are they going to depend on this "perpetual baby walker" when the baby walker itself cannot be sure if it is going to break down tomorrow? i believe if kids do not stand up and take their first step and perhaps experience a few falls, they never grow up as healthy children. as parents, i think everyone should accept the fact that falls are normal things when a child learns to walk on its own and become good experience to them. depriving them of the chance to do so would have a negative effect and retard their development. if this subject of "protectiveness" is to be brought to the extreme, i am of the opinion that those concerned might as well apply to the "world wildlife fund" to be listed as a "protected species facing extinction".   
  

Nama 

FAIR

Alamat Elektronik 

teetee4.hotmail.com

Pendapat 

Saya 100% sokong kepada pihak jawatankuasa suqiu.tindakan yang dilakukan oleh P.UMNO amat mengecewakan .

Nama 

Steven

Alamat Elektronik 

pengbt@

Pendapat 

I was borned in Malaysia, study and living in Malaysia. Anyhow i feel very annoyed when i was asked to fill in the form to differentiate from bumiputra/nonbumiputra.   
Well, how do you say you are a bumiputra?, a native Malay? orang Asli, Malay cross with Indian, cross with Pakistan, Mat Salleh , or Negros long time ago also consider as bumiputra?   
Is there any scientific way to differentiate that such as DNA test or whatsoever because majority of `Malay' what i see now actually a mixture/cross.   
Actually i raised this issue not because i am anti Malay but just to discuss it openly if Malay, and Malaysian particularly want to be progress.   
A progress and developed nation shouldnt have any topic which is considered `sensitive'   
Those who born in Malaysia should be considered as bumiputra because we are the prince/princess of this earth.   
I believe most Malaysian and intelligent Malay can understand this princple and analogue:   
Example in one family, (our country), if certain children are given special previlage,   
1. What are the feeling of other children? Even though they are from the same parents, given birth in the same place, Malaysia.How do you expect this family to be harmony? each will be envy on each other.   
analogue: all races, Malay, Chinese, Indian etc are born in Malaysia and with the same parents, our PM, and ministers.   
taking care of us. We are not migrate from other countries.   
Why only certain races are given special previlage? We can understand if we are not born here,not special previlage be given that's normal and understood. No matter how the government everyday say Malaysia Boleh, we still cant live in harmony because certain group are receiving special previlage while others not because all of them are born in Malaysia. if you query chinese ancestor are migrant, how about those mixed blood malay whose ancestor also migrant???   
  
2. From sociology study, a lot of problem children who committed to criminal, lazy and create a lot of social problem is from the family who always pampered or give special previlage to the certain children.   
Giving special previlage to certain races, means that pampering the race and tongkat theory as mentioned by our PM   
and this can explain why 80% of Mara sponsored student to overseas never pay back the loan and hardly get a degree or whatever certificate and enjoy their life in overseas,   
Giving special previlage to them means that giving fish to them without teaching them to fishing.   
Actually Malay are intelligent and their IQ are comparable with other races, why so scared/no confident that they cant compete with other races?? or they think that malay are born stupid and really need help otherwise they cant survive, by setting up Quota or whatsoever discrimination policy, just the system and the implementation make them leave behind other races. They cant progress not because they are Malay but the system make them handicapped.   
Actually the ball is under their feet, if they want to be intelligent and progress as other race or meet the global standard as Singapore Malay example, they should request themself to abolish the special previlage themself, if they can think logically and think on the shoe of other race.   
I would very appreciate if i can get a comment from SINGAPORE MALAY...a Malay that didnt enjoy special previlage as in Malaysia.   
I am very very sure that the Malay race will remain Me`layu', if the special previlage remains and the race wont progress and strong enough to meet the global world,   
just like one family which the special child receving special previlage/pampered from the parents never success in the life. I would like to challenge anybody who can proved that i am wrong.   

Nama 

Robert

Alamat Elektronik 

anak@Malaysia.com

Pendapat 

tidak boleh dinafikan , dulu saya memang peyokong kuat BN .   
Tetapi lepas pilihanraya , apa yang kita dapat,  kenaikan Tol , petrol , tambang bas ..... ..Ia hanya menguntungkan   sesetengah pihak...( orang kaya=lagi kaya , orang miskin=   lagi miskin )   
  
Saya setuju dengan Mr. Anak Islah ,sesetengah pihak yang cuma mengapi-apikan sentimen perkauman   
dulu Astro ,sekarang Suqiu , masa depan ????   
Apa yang dulu BN janjikan masa pilihanraya ( membina sekolah-sekolah cina yang baru,   mengekalkan keharmonian semua kaum,....) all BULLSH*T   
  
SUQIU adalah untuk semua rakyat Malaysia yang cintakan negara MALAYSIA . bukan saja cina ,   
malah untuk orang melayu , orang india .....   
  
kita haruslah sentiasa berwaspada pada akhbar-akhbar yang suka  memain-mainkan sentimen perkauman seperti utusan melayu..   
  
DIsini , saya dan kawan-kawan saya berjanji . kita akan menyokong Barisan Alternative dari sekarang   
  
TO KAK AZIZAH , Teruskan perjuangan anda untuk semua rakyat Malaysia   
Long Life PAS , Parti KeAdilan ,DAP  KERANAMU MALAYSIA   
  
Thank Mr. Anak Islah . You are right.orang-orang Melayu tahu   apa yang berlaku tapi orang cina   
sampaikah bila you akan INSAF ??   

Nama 

DC

Alamat Elektronik 

presence@mail.com

Pendapat 

Sudiu, stand up for your principles. If there apologies, it should come from Umno Youth for the abusive reaction. What happened to the Barison spirit of "we are all one same family" By the way, how is it that Umno Youth can have a public demo without police interference? Is this a special rights for umnoputra or what? If the Malays needed special help, then help should be extended to all poor malays , chinese and Indians. Not just Umno youth members. Just a month ago Aziz said any kind of demonstration are intolerable in peaceful Malaysia. What say you ,Suhakam?   

Nama 

bersatu

Alamat Elektronik 

bersatu@hotmail.com

Pendapat 

Kita adalah rakyat Malaysia, tak kira bangsa dan agama, apa tujuan sebenarnya pihak tertentu untuk membangkitkan isu ini ?Ia hanya satu rayuan sahaja?sudah satu genap tahun.Barulah sekarang mempersoalkan rayuan ini?Seperti kita yang ketahui, Siapa yang berkuasa sekarang?Adakah Kedudukan Bumiputera tergugat sekarang?Janganlah bertindak mengikut perasaan.Tindakan tunjuk perasaan tidak menjejas persahabatan antara kawan saya!!!Saya ada kawan Melayu,India dan sebagainya.Bagi Kawan Melayu saya, dia seorang yg serdehana pemikirannya dan dia juga berpendapat bahawa rayuan ini adalah munasabah.Lagipun, ia hanya satu cadangan sahaja. Saya tak faham kenapa pemuda Umno anggap Kaum Cina adalah kaum pendatang. sekarang semua rakyat Malaysia adalah dilahirkan di Tempat Malaysia.Kaum masing-masing menyumbang jasa kepada negara.Saya dan kawan-kawan saya juga berasa sedih kerana ada slogan yg dipaparkan oleh Pemuda Umno iaitu   
Malay= Malaysia....Apa maksudnya?amat sedih dan hampa kerana ada gologan yg berfikiran sempit..........................

Nama 

Joe

Alamat Elektronik 

jj@hotmail.com

Pendapat 

Appeals are correct but we have to do it with wisdom.   
  
Remember that everybody wants to be treated as important and everybody resists to changes, not just Malay. You are attacking them from their toes up to their heads.   
  
Don't try to rush. Do things bit by bit! Instead of 17 Appeals, try just 3 each time. It is slow but it may work.   
  
Abolishing aborigine's privileges won't work even in Australia, don't talk about Malaysia.   
  
Best wishes,   
Student in Australia.   

Nama 

HUMAN

Alamat Elektronik 

Pendapat 

Hmm...I strongly believe everybody is equal.Well allow me to ask you a question:-   
  
A healthy baby, you feed them until adult, would you feel any frustration that they have reached aroud 30 years old and still have to feed them although they are healthy? What I mean healthy just like us, able to move, taste, walk, think, run, feel, see and so on. But there is one problem, they don't wanna do it or even try it even thought they have healthy body. Just keep on been feed for the rest of their life! just lying down like dead meat! If they are handicap that's another story.   
  
I feel teribly shame if I was one of them. Why? I unable to enjoy my life, wakeup and experience the many wonderful things in this world. Healthy person unable to use owm strenght to wakeup? I have to tell you, if I was one of them, I rather leave this world and not wasting time to lie on here without moving. I hate being bored to death!   
  
So what do you think?

Nama 

Anak Islah

Alamat Elektronik 

Pendapat 

Tolong jangan membalas provokasi mereka yang mempunyai agenda sendiri.   
  
Sebagai seorang anak Malaysia yang cintakan tanahair, saya memohon kepada supaya semua pelawat laman ini yang patriotik supaya tidak terpedaya dengan perangkap sesetengah pihak yang cuma mengapi-apikan sentimen perkauman. Kalau anda terpedaya, gembiralah mereka sebagaimana mereka gembira melihat demostrasi yang aman menjadi huru-hara kerana makan umban provokasi.   
  
Wahai saudara-saudaraku, percayalah bahawa orang-orang Melayu tahu apa yang berlaku. Respon anda yang emosional cuma akan diperalatkan untuk menfitnah Suqiu di kalangan rakyat yang tidak mendapat informasi benar. Janganlah terperangkap. Bersabarlah !   
  
Sepertimana yang dikatakan oleh Tok Guru Nik Aziz yang kita   
hormati, persoalan pokok di sini bukanlah kaum, tetapi kemiskinan. Siapa yang miskin, maka siapa harus diberi bantuan. Suqiu sememangnya tidak menyentuh Hak Keistimewaan Orang Melayu. Jadi penyokong Suqiu tidak harus membangkitkan perkara ini pada dewasa ini.   
  
Meneruskan perjuangan anda untuk semua orang Malaysia ! Bersabarlah ! Berkawanlah lebih orang Melayu supaya konspirasi UMNO tidak akan berjaya.   
  
Insya Allah, perkembangan mengenai Suqiu ini akhirnya merapatkan rakyat Malaysia yang berlainan keturunan dan kepercayaan.   
  
Semoga Malaysia kita diberkati !

Nama 

Supporter

Alamat Elektronik 

tekchiang@hotmail.com

Pendapat 

I am very appreciate action and opinion of PAS leader, our Chinese leader only challenge to abolish the you1 hui4 of 1970 New Economic policy, not challenge 1957 xian4 fa3 Malay special right.   
But PAS leader challenge all, want to abolish all.   
Please support PAS!

Nama 

melayu

Alamat Elektronik 

melayu@umno.org

Pendapat 

Orang cina sepatutnya belajar dari MCA & Gerakan yang   tidak mempersoalkan hak orang Melayu. Orang Melayu   
adalah pemilik asal Tanah Melayu. Manakala orang cina   hanyalah kaum pendatang.   
  
Hidup Melayu!   
Hidup Umno!   
Hidup Mahathir!   
Hidup Pemuda Umno!

Nama 

keh long

Alamat Elektronik 

kehlong@hotmail.com

Pendapat 

To Dr. Mahathir,   
I strongly support the viewpoints you expressed in the 1996 UMNO general assembly. To competitively compete on a global scale in the globalisation era, the Malays should no longer depend on the 'tongkat' courtesy of the government.   
  
To SuQiu Committee,   
Syabas! You have taken the initiative to struggle for a better future for our beloved country despite the brutal resistance by certain quarters.   
  
To the Alternative Front in general, and PAS in particular,   
All Malaysians are glad to know of your open-mindedness. We hope to see full commitment from all of you. We are looking forward to reforming the political scenario of the country gradually. Teruskan perjuangan!   
  
To Utusan Melayu,   
We know your agenda. Malays are not stupid. Don't try to manipulate them! Watch your circular rate dropping every day. Gulunglah tikar!   
  
To UMNO Youth,   
Malaysia boleh, kenapa Melayu tak boleh?   
  
To Abdul Aziz (the ##### who lead the demonstration)   
Face a mirror, think! Insaflah.   
  
KeranaMu Malaysia.

Nama 

Supporter

Alamat Elektronik 

tekchiang@hotmail.com

Pendapat 

I hope who not support suqiu, especially the Malay racism people, don't leave your ugly message here, don't pollute our Chinese SUQIU website. You want Malay racism or support UMNO please go to their website.

Tarikh 

8/24/2000

Jawab 

Dear supporter,   
  
Thanks for your support for Suqiu. However,We would like to stress that Suqiu as well as its website is for all malaysian. Let us remind each other : if we are not Malaysian-minded, then we will be near to those who play with ethnic sentiments.   
  
Secretariat

 

 

 

Nama 

Kwek

Alamat Elektronik 

kwek@maxis.net.my

Pendapat 

If we can't abolish the special right of Malay now, that is no way, because now BN 2/3 in parliament until 2004, but we must find another chance to abolish special right, cannot abandon our hope to get fair of our citizenship. Now defeat to abolish it not means we lost, we must have confident to accomplish our purpose. THAT IS ABOLISH SPECIAL RIGHT, NO RACE HAVE SPECIAL RIGHT, ALL HUMAN ARE EQUAL.

Nama 

Dicca Tan

Alamat Elektronik 

dicca@hotmail.com

Pendapat 

No apology, no kau tow.   
Rather to die standing tall with principles,  than to live miserably with bowed head.   
Chinese are no second class citizens,   unless they make themselves out to be such.   
So don't throw away the dignity of the race,   for you may never recover them again.

Nama 

DAVY

Alamat Elektronik 

Khsiu@tm.net.my

Pendapat 

First of all I would like to congratulate you and your committee for being very sensible and patient in dealing with disageement instead of taking action like - an eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth! Keep up the good work. The formation of MALAYSIA was not without conditions and the conditions have been discussed in length and breath, may be under close door (I don't know really) before MALAYSIA was formed in 1963 with Sabah, Sarawak (and Singapore which was later dropped) taking part. Now all conditions have been written down. My opinion is like this:Since the conditioins are the result of discussions I see there is no reason why as a Malaysian we are not allowed to discuss the matter again at length and breath--may be a better condition can be again written down. There is no reason for quarrel (racial quarrel) because when the conditions were first discussed before the formation of MALAYSIA there was no quarrel! We all can speak out our opinions only. We do not make any decision. It is up to the top level to make decision to crack their brain out to think for a better conditions to be written down. If the top level cannot make any decision then the best decision is to stick to the existing conditions and let the next generations to discuss and decide for a better conditions to be WRITTEN DOWN! We, as true Malaysian should be allowed to express our opinions freely without fear of being terminated in our own land MALAYSIA. Let us stand up and tell the world that we can do so!

Nama 

Wei

Alamat Elektronik 

weichee@maxis.net.my

Pendapat 

This is a very good website!!I will always support this website!

Nama 

Wei

Alamat Elektronik 

weichee@maxis.net.my

Pendapat 

Pemuda UMNO tidak seharusnya bertindak begitu!!Pergerakan Pemuda UMNO amat mengecewakan!!Tidak dapat dinafikan, soal hak istimewa Melayu telah menyingung perasaan antara rakyat Malaysia(bukan sahaja kaum Melayu dan Cina).Sesetengah Hak istimewa Melayu harus dihapuskan(bukan semua).Bagi mecapai kemajuan dan perpaduan antara bangsa,tolerence antara dua pihak amat penting!!! Pergerakan agresif antara dua pihak tidak seharus berlaku seperti 513.......

Nama 

soh

Alamat Elektronik 

nil

Pendapat 

I fully support the effort put up by suqiu committte.   
All human being are born equal. I just don't understand why certain group of race require special privileges. Special treatment should be accorded to the poor and handicap only.   
All human with four limbs should be treated equally.   
To all suqiu committe member,Keep up the good work! You need to persevere in your struggle.

Nama 

fei

Alamat Elektronik 

nsw2000@hotmail.com

Pendapat 

I hope people accessing this site will be a sensible, civilised, considerate one. This matter concerning all people and all races in Malaysia and someone who called "melayu" mention racial riot and killing people is totally not sensible. Now we see, who try to provoke this matter? We use all the appropriate matter to solve the problem but someone just want people in Malaysia killing each other, does this make any sense? So, I hope people who don't have constructive idea and view please don't ever access to this site again.

Nama 

cheng feng

Alamat Elektronik 

cheng_feng@hotmail.com

Pendapat 

I 100% support the suqiu commitee . Don't care what the other people said.

Nama 

webcitizen

Alamat Elektronik 

webcitizen@hotmail.com

Pendapat 

I demand David Chua to resign!!!!!   
Because he is stupid & collaborate with Mahathir to make   
the chinese community bogeyman.   
    
##### #### ## ####### ###!!!!!!!!!   
   
see what happen now!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Nama 

melayu

Alamat Elektronik 

azzism@themail.com

Pendapat 

Kaum cina sekalian dan sekumpulan anggota suqiu.   
Apakah tuntutan kamu terhadap pelupusan hak keistimewaan kaum melayu telah di kaji. Apa bezanya dengan hak kamu di malaysia ini. Adakah sepatutnya orang-orang melayu menunut supaya hak kaum cina dilucutkan taraf warganegaranya...seperti yang telah kita persetujui lama dulu, melayu dengan hak keistimewaanya dan cina dengan hak kewarganegaraannya.   
  
janganlah cuba membangkitkan hak kaum melayu di tanah melayu dan tanah kami ini, ini adalah tanah kami orang-orang melayu dan bukannya tanah kaum cina. Satu inci diusik tanah kami ini, akan kami pertahankan selamanya. Hak kami bukannnya untuk kaum cina. Perjuangan kami melayu seluruhnya akan mempertahankan keutuhan tanah melayu dan bukannnya untuk kaum cina. Kalau orang cina hendakkan hak keistimewaan atau sebagainya, pulanglah ke negara asal kamu...Negara China dan tuntutlah hak kamu sekalian di sana. Ini tanah melayu dan hak kami untuk selamanya.   
AWAS KAUM CINA...   
JANGAN SEINCI HAK KAMI DIUSIK...   

Nama 

ken ooi

Alamat Elektronik 

ken.ooi@talk21.com

Pendapat 

Dear Malaysian,   
I am so disappointed, after being through so many years   (43 years) of independence, I wonder do we grow up with   
that?   We, Malays, Chineses, Indians, and some minority races are  under the same roof of Malaysia society shouldn't let this   incident happen again. I believe that the UMNO PEMUDA have   what in their mind by doing this unnecessary movement,   because of their unknown. Therefore, I strongly support the  Suqiu Committee. If the apologies are needed will be from   UMNO PEMUDA unwisely action.   

Nama 

tan say kiong

Alamat Elektronik 

simon_98pbc@yahoomail.com

Pendapat 

pada pendapat saya, saya menyokong dengan tindakan tidak meminta maaf . pada zaman yang mengutamakan keadilan dan kesaksamaan, hak istimewa perlu diberikan kepada semuagolongan kaum yang memerlukan, seperti golongan bawahan yang miskin.kaum cina dan india juga mempunyai golongan miskin.siapa yang bantu mereka???tuhan ataupun kerajaan?situasi ini akan menjadikan orang miskin terus miskin dan orang kaya lebih kaya.Dengan itu hak istimewa perlu dikaji dan diubahsuai.

Nama 

pemuda

Alamat Elektronik 

aaaa@tm.net.my

Pendapat 

  
Wahai Kawan , adakah anda sudah baca and memahami SUQIU ?   
Kalau sudah . sila beritahu saya yang mana satu ada   
mengiatkan penghapusan Keistimewaan HAK-HAK ORANG MELAYU ????   
  
kita orang melayu ,jangan salahkan orang lain ,kita harus   
memahami ini adalah pembuatan setengah pihak untuk kita   
melupakan pemimpin yang tak berdosa ini ( DATUK SRI ANWAR   
IBRAHIM )   
  
KAK AZIZAH .Teruskan Perjuangan anda   
WE SUPPORT " YOU AND PARTI KEADILAN "

Nama 

webcitizen

Alamat Elektronik 

webcitizen@hotmail.com

Pendapat 

Have you (suqiu) learn you lesson.?????????   
Hopefully there will be no third time.   
I'don't understand why Suqiu is been use again and again by   
BN propaganda machine (Utusan) for their political mileage.   
Suqiu have you learn your mistake??   
David Chua, I hope you will not repeat your mistake.   
You are not stupid, so don't let they use you, ok!   
If it happen again, disassociate yourself from any chinese entiti,just say you are representing the monkey in the   
jungle.   
  

Nama 

Wooi Kia

Alamat Elektronik 

wooikia@hotmail.com

Pendapat 

I am a University Student who is currently studying in Australia. I've been reading all the news concerning the SuQiu and i am here to condemn Pemuda UMNO who acted like the uncivilized people, also, at the same time i would like to convey my warmest regards and supports to SuQiu who has been working hard to defend chinese's rights.   
  
We got a group of students who are keen to help SuQiu, but could you please let us know, how can we help ?

Nama 

ʫ

Alamat Elektronik 

Pendapat 

Jangan andaikan Suqui wakili majoriti Cina   
  
Semua pihak diminta agar tidak mengandaikan bahawa Jawatankuasa Rayuan Pilihanraya Persatuan-Persatuan Cina Malaysia (Suqui) sebagai mewakili majoriti masyarakat Cina di negara ini.   
  
Suqui hanya mewakili sebahagian kecil komuniti Cina, justeru tidak mencerminkan sikap serta fahaman kebanyakan kaum itu.   
  
Kami tidak mempertikaikan sebarang hak keistimewaan orang Melayu, kerana ia sudah pun termaktub dalam Perlembagaan Persekutuan, kita tidak pernah mempersoalkannya.   
  
Buktinya adalah sokongan padu yang diberikan oleh rakyat kaum Tionghua terhadap Barisan Nasional (BN) dalam pilihan raya umum lalu.   
  
(Semalam, Pergerakan Pemuda UMNO telah menyerahkan memorandum bantahan kepada Suqui yang mendesak supaya ia menarik balik semua tuntutannya dan memohon maaf kepada seluruh orang Melayu dalam tempoh seminggu.)   
  
(Bagaimanapun Suqui dalam reaksinya bertegas tidak akan menarik balik 17 tuntutannya termasuk menuntut pemansuhan perbezaan status bumiputera dan bukan bumiputera dalam semua bidang.)   
  
Pemuda MCA memandang berat terhadap kenyataan beberapa pemimpin Melayu yang dianggapnya sebagai keterlaluan.   
  
Kenyataan melulu mereka seolah-olah menyalahkan keseluruhan kaum Tionghua, saya harap mereka lebih berhati-hati kerana ia boleh mengeruhkan lagi keadaan.   
  
Ia boleh menyinggung perasaan umum orang-orang Tionghua yang sebenarnya tidak ada kena mengena dengan Suqui dan merupakan penyokong kuat kerajaan selama ini, janganlah 'kerana marahkan nyamuk kelambu pula dibakar', ujarnya.   
  
Pihak kami amat berdukacita terhadap kenyataan, kelakuan serta kejadian-kejadian yang berlaku berikutan isu tuntutan Suqui itu.   
  
Ada pihak yang akan mengambil kesempatan ke atas apa yang berlaku untuk memburukkan negara dan menegakkan agenda masing-masing.   
  
Buat apa kita pula beri modal pada mereka untuk menjahanamkan diri kita sendiri, seperti kata orang, 'menang sorak, kampung tergadai'   
  
Saya berharap semua pihak dapat bertenang dan menghormati semangat yang mahu disemai kerajaan melalui sambutan bulan kemerdekaan yang sedang giat dilangsungkan sekarang.   
  
(dipetik daripada Utusan Malaysia

Nama 

Lee Chuan Wa

Alamat Elektronik 

leecwa@hotmail.com

Pendapat 

Dear Commitee Member of Suqiu,   
  
Your philosophy, intention and effort to make Malaysia a more   open and accountable place to live is much appreciated.   
  
On the way to achieve the above, you would most certainly face  a lot of hindrance.The recent intentionally misinterpretation   of Suqiu is but one of them. We should galvernise the associations  ad societies who had signed the Suqiu to show the solidality   and the feeling of the community to be heard.   
  
Don't be discouraged, you have my humble support.   
  
All the best. Onwards with Suqiu.   
  
leechuanwa

Nama 

ps lee

Alamat Elektronik 

samuel_lee26@hotmail.com

Pendapat 

i think the incident last few day ago where pemuda umno had done can not be accepted by all malaysia's chinese and i think we can not simply let this happened again because we were all Malaysian and there should not specified or separate even in religous,race and others. finally i would like to say that i will fully support suqiu and be confidence with what we had done and do what we wish to do. thank.

Nama 

Abu Naquib

Alamat Elektronik 

shafana@tm.net.my

Pendapat 

Saudara-saudara sekelian,   
  
Suasana semasa yang timbul akibat, hasutan media sangat mengecewakan.   Saya berpendapat bahawa saudara perlu mengambil langkah yang sesuai   untuk memperbaiki keadaan. Yang jelas pada pemerhatian saya adalah:-   
  
1. SUQIU berada pada landasan yang betul untuk mengujudkan suasana   negara ynag lebih baik untuk generasi akan datang   
2. SUQIU tidak bersikap perkauman malah memperjuangkan hak individu   yang hidup dalam zaman serta undang-undang negara yang menggongkong   kebebasan.  

3. Pihak tertentu cuba menjadikan SUQIU sebagai kambing hitam dalam   ajenda politik peribadi yang sempit lagi kotor.   
  
Saya selaku seorang rakyat Malaysia merayu agar SUQIU memulakan langkah   sendiri untuk menerangkan kebenaran kepada seluruh rakyat Malaysia.   SUQIU tidak perlu berhadapan dengan "mereka" kerana SUQIU adalah milek   rakyat Malaysia maka rakyat Malaysia yang harus tahu tentang kebenaran   dan keadilan yang di perjuangkan.   
  
Abu Naquib.   
Johor.

Nama 

chan tl

Alamat Elektronik 

Pendapat 

Dear Mr. Quek,   
  
After reading your laugh of the memorandum so   called "Suqui". I am proud of the Malaysia Chinese  Association so as, the chinese community because they   finally united and stood up to shout out their long   hidden unhappy voice. I am a chinese originally from   a small town in Taiping, and is currently doing my   Ph.D. study in U.K under the scholarship from British   Government. However, Malaysian government never helps   me in any ways to get this education. As a chinese   that born in Taiping, I was long had enough of all the   government nonsense regarding of the special privilege   
for Malay and Bumiputra. I still remember while I was studying in a chinese primary school, my school always  organized Marathon, Walkathon, and etc in order to   collect funds from publics and parents to keep the   school running. This is because our government has   little concern about Non-Bumiputra race, and not much   financial support has been given in Chinese and Tamil   education institution. Guess you already know about   this.   
  
Why only this particular race should be helped, and   that race shouldn't be help? Why Malay can study in   overseas without worrying about their financial   problem and no concern about what result the student might obtained. For the last five years in overseas   university, I have seen many of the Malay students   failed in their studies. Most students never   
appreciate what the government had given to them, and   when asked why they don't work to achieve good   results; they answered " Tak Kisah lah, Bukan Saya   Punya Wang Asalkan Saya Sudah Enjoy Cukup lah". I   would say majority of sponsored Malay students in   whole United Kingdom would have the same thinking.   Besides that, the worst thing that I ever found out   was many of the Malay sponsored students in overseas   were not from poor family. Some of their parents were   Lawyer, Minister, Doctor, Engineer and etc, so why are  these students still eligible to get the scholarship?   Aren't this scholarship package should be given to   poor student who has the intelligent, and most of all  are keen to learn. If you recall can announcement   from our Minister Dr. Mahathir few years back, he said   that more than 80% of the student who obtained their   higher education through government grants, have never   bother to repay back their loans. So is this kind of attitude that Malaysian should be? Actually, the   government is just teaching them to be an   irresponsible and dependent people just like a   Parasite.   
  
I wish you could understand that I am not writing this   letter to tell you my hatred against Malay nor create   war in between our races, Malay, Chinese and Tamil.   In fact, I want to let you know that I appreciate the   work you have done and I will support you in all ways.   As well as to create a new generation of Malaysian in   which, all level of communities in the country will   share the equal and fair treatments from the   government.   
  
With thanks.   
  

Nama 

Andy Yang

Alamat Elektronik 

Pendapat 

Saya sebagai seorang bangsa cina,saya amat berbangga  atas apa yang diperjuangkan oleh pihak tuan untuk angsa kita.Akan tetapi,jika tuan meminta kerajaan   yang dikuasai oleh kaum bukan cina itu untuk  meluluskan tuntutan pihak tuan sebanyak 17 perkara,ini   adalah tidak mungkin.Hanya meminta kerajaan   menghapuskan hak istimewa kaum melayu dalam bidang   ekonomi sudah tidak diizinkan.Saya di sini ingin beri  sedikit komen.Pihak tuan patut memperjuangkan hak   bangsa cina secara perlahan-lahan.Sebagai contoh,pihak tuan boleh mula dari segi pendidikan yang amat tidak   adil kepada bangsa kita yang pendidikan itu yang   merupakan asas perjuangan segala perkara.Ini kerana   kaum india pun tidak menyokong pihak tuan yang mereka   dapat apa yang mereka.    

 

Nama 

Lee Chua

Alamat Elektronik 

Pendapat 

Dear all: I write to express solidarity with suqiu members on the work they  do to help Malaysia become a just, free nation where all peoples can develop  to their fullest potential. At present, they are people who'd deliberately  distort your purpose for ulterior motives. These same people will even go so   far as to intimidate individual suqiu members. I urge all suqiu members to   stand firm. Debts of blood will one day be repaid in blood. May God be with  you.   
  
regards,   
Lee Chua   

 

 

 

 

Nama 

C T Khor

Alamat Elektronik 

khorct@pop.jaring.my

Pendapat 

We are proud to be Malaysian because we can live in a peaceful and happy country since Merdeka in 1957. Malaysian enjoyed the unique way of living, rich of multi-cultural and understanding between multi-racial society. All Malaysian are working together and we have been proven our capabilities to handle the Asia Financial Crisis and prevent the subsersive of communism. I feel very regret the incident happened this afternoon in Selangor   
Chinese Town Hall. The misunderstanding between UMNO Youth and Suqiu Committee could be avoided if we could listen and respect each others.   MALAYSIA BOLEH is a good foundation to encourage Malaysian more mature, positive thinking, broad perspective. If we choice to be   negative and extreme, a heaven could turn into hell. I wish all parties concerned must find way to soften the situation. Especially media must stop negative reports immediately.  report more true picture and fact, but not emotion or misuse by political agenda.   
  
Malays need more support to strengthen their economic, education and know-how, Chinese are the good partner to help them.   Again, majority of Malays are very friendly, mesra, moderate, etc. could strengthen the relationship other races in Malaysia.   Our common enemies are corruption, abuse of power, poverty, wasting of resources. All partical parties, NGOs, leaders, senior   citizen must work together, norrow the gap of difference for betterment of Malaysian. Angry, conflict, bias show our weaknesses,   however, understanding, perservance,wisdom and loving kindness should be the way to learn by all Malaysia.   
  
I sincerely urge UMNO Youth and Suqiu Committee to resolve the unforeseen circumstance amicably.   
  
Thanks & Regards   

Nama 

nataraja

Alamat Elektronik 

nataraja@ms43.url.com.tw

Pendapat 

Big 5 Chinese please!

Nama 

Lee Keo Boon

Alamat Elektronik 

Lee.Keowin@netease.com

Pendapat 

Hai,saya berasal dari Pulau Hainan, Republik Rakyat China. Ayah saya pernah bertempur darah dengan tentera Jepun lebih kurang sepuluh tahun lamanya sebagai seorang anggota Parti Komunis Malaya, dan demi untuk usaha memperjuangkan kemerdekaan negara Malaysia, beliau serta kawan-kawannya sebernarnya sudah memberi banyak sumbangan kepada Malaysia. Adakah kemungkinan kami merayu kepada kerajaan Malaysia supaya memberikan pengakuan pada generasi ini?   
Salam mesra daripada saya.   
  
Lee Keo Boon

Nama 

James Chiang

Alamat Elektronik 

James__68@hotmail.com

Pendapat 

This site is an interesting site.. but unfortunately , not many of us can read chinese. I am a chinese but i can't read chinese as my parents encouraged me to learn more on English and Bahasa Melayu. If possible please have it written in Malay or English.

I have read about your appeals in the newspaper and i personally think that it is outrageous. To have a better country , we have to have stability and coorperation between races. So as to that, Malays as we see is still a poor race so they need all the help they can get to improve themselves and together with us to bring up the country.Most Malays think that we Chinese are selfish and ignorant and cruel. They have given up so much so that we could have a decent place to live and is this what we are repaying back to them. I know i don't have the right to say this but it is better to leave things as they are.